Written cash offer within 24 hours of the walkthrough
Sell Your Bay Shore House For Cash, From The Bay Blocks To North Of Sunrise
A Direct Cash Buyer For Bay Shore Homeowners, Landlords, And Estates Who Want A Closing Without Repairs, Showings, Or Surprises.
Get Your Cash Offer Today
Fill out this quick form and we'll get back to you within 24 hours.
Your information is private and never shared.
or
Call Us 516-218-0365or
One ZIP Code, Two Bay Shores, And We Buy In Both
South of Montauk Highway, Bay Shore is the ferry town: the Fire Island boats leaving Maple Avenue, the creek streets along Awixa and Penataquit, older houses on Saxon, Clinton, and Ocean Avenue that took water in October 2012 and never fully came back. Main Street filled in with restaurants and the Boulton Center, and South Shore University Hospital anchors the east end. North of Sunrise Highway it’s a different town: 1950s and 60s capes and ranches off Brentwood Road and Fifth Avenue, a lot of them cut into two units, a fair number of them somewhere in the foreclosure process.
The Town of Islip handles permits for all of it, most of the hamlet sits on the Southwest Sewer District, and the Montauk branch station is the reason half the owners bought here. Prime Realty Buyers buys in both halves. The bay block with the Sandy repairs that were never finished, the two family off Brentwood Road with a tenant who stopped paying, the Victorian near Main Street that’s been an estate for two years, the cape with a sale date. We can close on a Bay Shore house in as little as 7 days.
Trusted By Bay Shore Homeowners In:
the bay blocks south of Montauk Highway, the Awixa and Penataquit creek streets, the Main Street blocks, the station area, West Bay Shore, and North Bay Shore, plus surrounding Suffolk communities including Brightwaters, Brentwood, Islip, West Islip, Central Islip, and Islip Terrace.
Why Bay Shore Homeowners Sell To Prime Realty Buyers
Bay Shore houses fail retail sales for two very different reasons. South of Montauk Highway it’s the flood zone: elevation certificates, insurance quotes, a Sandy repair that never got its permit. North of Sunrise it’s the second unit, the tenant, and the mortgage. Either way the deal dies at the lender.
Sellers across Bay Shore reach out to us when they're dealing with:
We make a direct cash offer and walk you through it. Flood zone, tenant, permit, or probate, we tell you honestly whether we’re the right buyer.
We Buy Bay Shore Houses As-Is
You don’t raise the house. You don’t finish the Sandy repairs. You don’t evict the tenant.
We buy:
Take what matters. Leave the rest. The unfinished repairs, the tenant, and the contents are ours the day we close.
Why Choose Prime Realty Buyers
Prime Realty Buyers is a local Long Island buyer. We close in Bay Shore and across the Town of Islip every month, and the person who walks your house is the person who writes the offer. We explain the number, including what we factored in for the flood zone, the tenant, or the unfinished repairs, and we send proof of funds when you ask.
We work with your attorney, your executor, and your timeline, in English or Spanish. If the estate needs the summer, the house waits. If the only weekend the heirs can get to Bay Shore is in August, we close around it and nobody has to come back twice.
Situations We Buy Bay Shore Houses In
Nearby Suffolk Areas We Also Buy In
We buy along the South Shore of the Town of Islip and in the communities around Bay Shore, including:
Real Bay Shore Seller Stories
Flood Zone
Our house on Saxon Avenue took four feet of water in Sandy. We rebuilt the first floor ourselves and never pulled the permit. Two buyers walked once their insurance quotes came in. Chris walked it, said the flood zone was priced in, and Prime Realty Buyers closed in 21 days. No elevation certificate, no engineer, no third quote. We finally moved up to Islip Terrace.
Inherited House
My grandmother’s house near Main Street had been sitting for two years while my aunt in Georgia and my brother in Oregon argued about fixing it. Prime Realty Buyers bought it with everything inside, arranged their signings by mail, and closed in five weeks. Chris was the only person who explained the offer to all three of us at once instead of picking sides.
Repair Distress
The roof on our cape north of Sunrise had been leaking into the second floor for a year, and the boiler was from the seventies. Nobody would finance it. Chris didn’t ask us to fix a thing. Prime Realty Buyers priced the roof and the boiler into the offer, showed us how, and closed in 18 days. We took the bedroom furniture and left the rest.
Downsizing
Forty one years in the same house off Awixa Avenue, and my husband couldn’t do the stairs anymore. We didn’t want strangers walking through or a sign on the lawn where everyone knows us. Prime Realty Buyers came once, made the offer the next day, and gave us until our apartment was ready. Closed in seven weeks, on the date we picked. Quiet, which is what we wanted.
Landlord Headache
I bought a two family off Brentwood Road as an investment and it turned into a second job. The upstairs tenant stopped paying in 2023 and the case dragged on in Central Islip. Prime Realty Buyers bought it occupied, took the case with it, and closed in 26 days. Chris never once asked me to get the unit empty first.
Sound Like Your Situation?
One walkthrough, a written cash offer in 24 hours, no obligation.
Our 3-Step Process
1
Contact Us
Call 516-218-0365 or submit your property information. Tell us the Bay Shore address, the situation, and your timeline. Five minutes, no obligation.
2
Get A Fair Cash Offer
We do a quick walkthrough, in person or virtual, and present a no-obligation cash offer, usually within 24 hours. We’ll show you exactly how we got to the number.
3
Close On Your Timeline
Need it done in seven days? We can. Need longer to settle an estate, coordinate a move, or wait out a tenant? We can do that too. You sign, we wire, you’re done.
Selling To Prime Realty Buyers Vs Listing In Bay Shore
| Sell To Prime Realty Buyers | Traditional Agent Sale |
|---|
| Condition | Sell 100% as-is | Repairs often needed |
| Commissions | 0% commissions | Agent commission comes out of your proceeds |
| Closing Costs | We cover closing costs | Seller pays a portion |
| Showings | No showings, no open houses | Weeks of showings over months |
| Timeline | Close in as little as 7 days | Contract, inspection, appraisal, and the lender’s timeline |
| Financing | No financing contingency | Deals fall apart at the mortgage commitment |
| Sandy Repairs Never Permitted | Bought as-is, Town of Islip paperwork on our side | Engineer letters and permits demanded before commitment |
| Flood Insurance Quote On A Creek Street | Priced into the offer, no policy needed to close | Buyer’s quote comes back and the deal dies |
| Converted Victorian With Three Units | Bought occupied, rent roll or not | Lender wants a CO for every unit and vacant possession |
| Cape North Of Sunrise With A Sale Date | Payoff from the lender, close before the auction | Rarely closes in time |
| Heirs In Georgia And Oregon | Mail away closing, remote notarized signings | Every signer at a local table |
| Basement Apartment Off Brentwood Road | We handle the Town after closing | Removal or a CO before the buyer’s bank commits |
Frequently Asked Questions, Bay Shore
My Bay Shore house south of Montauk Highway is in a flood zone. Do you still buy there?
Yes. The bay blocks and the creek streets are a large part of what we buy in Bay Shore. The flood zone is already in our number. You don’t get a quote, you don’t get an elevation certificate, and you don’t carry a policy for a buyer who might walk.
We rebuilt after Sandy without permits. Does the Town of Islip have to sign off before I sell to you?
No. We buy the house with the open paperwork and handle the Town of Islip on our side after closing. Unfinished or unpermitted Sandy repairs are common on the streets south of Montauk Highway, and they don’t slow us down.
Do you buy two family houses in Bay Shore with tenants who are behind?
Yes, occupied and behind is fine. We take on the tenancy, the case if there is one, and the unit as it stands. Nobody is asked to leave for a showing, and you never have to finish an eviction before we close.
The house is near Main Street and it's still in probate. Can you buy it now?
We can sign a contract now and close the week Surrogate’s Court issues Letters. Until then the house sits, no showings, no calls. If the estate is paying a flood policy and taxes in the meantime, closing quickly after Letters is where we save you money.
I'm behind on the mortgage on a house north of Sunrise Highway. How fast can you close?
As little as 7 days once title is clear. Call us as soon as you get a notice from the lender’s attorney. We get the payoff, close before any sale date, and you keep the equity that’s left.
Do I have to get a flood insurance quote or an elevation certificate for you?
No. We’re paying cash, so there’s no lender requiring either one. We know the Bay Shore flood maps and we price the zone into the offer ourselves.
What happens to the furniture and everything in the basement?
You take what you want and leave the rest. Furniture, appliances, the boxes in the garage, the boat trailer. We clear it after closing, not before.
Are there fees, commissions, or closing costs when I sell to Prime Realty Buyers?
None. 0% commissions, no closing costs charged to you, no fees of any kind. The written offer is what you walk away with, less only what you owe on the house.
Preguntas Frecuentes
Hablamos español. Llámenos al 516-218-0365.
¿Compran casas en Bay Shore que se inundaron con Sandy?
Sí. Compramos casas al sur de Montauk Highway en Bay Shore tal como están, aunque las reparaciones nunca tuvieran permiso. Prime Realty Buyers ya incluye la zona de inundación en la oferta.
¿Compran casas de dos familias con inquilinos atrasados en la renta?
Sí. Compramos la casa con los inquilinos adentro, estén pagando o no. Usted no tiene que desalojar a nadie antes de vender. Llámenos al 516-218-0365 para una oferta.
¿Qué tan rápido puede cerrar Prime Realty Buyers?
En tan solo 7 días si el título está limpio. Si usted necesita más tiempo para mudarse o terminar una sucesión, elige la fecha y nosotros la respetamos.
¿Tengo que reparar la casa antes de vender?
No. Compramos casas en Bay Shore con el techo dañado, la caldera vieja o el sótano sin terminar. Usted no repara nada ni limpia nada.
¿Cómo empiezo?
Llámenos al 516-218-0365 o envíenos la dirección. Hacemos una sola visita y le entregamos una oferta en efectivo por escrito en 24 horas, sin compromiso.
Ready To Sell Your Bay Shore House Fast?
No elevation certificate. No permits. No months of showings while the flood policy renews.A written cash offer from a local Long Island buyer who closes in Bay Shore every month.
No obligation. No pressure. No fees, ever.