Opens in a new tab
Welcome to Coney Island mural along a street with parked cars, Coney Island, Brooklyn, NY

After The Storm Years, A Cash Offer For Your Coney Island House

For Owners Of The Side-Street Houses, Two-Families, And Sea Gate Homes Who Want A Cash Sale Without Another Round Of Storm Repairs.
BBB Accredited BusinessPrime Realty Buyers Google reviews

Get Your Cash Offer Today

Fill out this quick form and we'll get back to you within 24 hours.

Google reCaptcha: Invalid site key.

Your information is private and never shared.
or
Call Us 516-218-0365
Long Island Press logo
Long Island Business News logo
The Suffolk Times logo
The Suffolk County News logo
realtor.com logo
Newsday logo
News 12 Long Island logo
New York Post logo
Massapequa Observer logo
LongIsland.com logo
LI Herald Five Towns logo
Forbes logo
CBS New York logo

The Houses Behind The Towers, From West 15th Street To Sea Gate

Most of Coney Island lives in apartment buildings, from NYCHA developments to newer rentals along Surf and Mermaid Avenues. This page is for the people who own the houses. They sit on the side streets between Mermaid and Neptune Avenues, from West 15th and West 16th Streets out to the West 30s, where older two- and four-family houses share the blocks with newer rowhouses built in recent decades. Past West 37th Street, Sea Gate’s private gate closes off an enclave of older houses that dates to the 1890s. The D, F, N, and Q end at Stillwell Avenue, the F and Q stop at West 8th Street, and the F stops at Neptune Avenue.

In October 2012 Sandy reached these blocks from two directions, over the beach on one side and out of Coney Island Creek on the other. Some houses were raised through Build It Back and now sit at the top of a long flight of stairs; others were patched room by room and never fully put back. Owners call about flood insurance that keeps climbing, a tenant in a two-family they no longer want to manage, or a parent’s house that went to heirs in other states. Prime Realty Buyers, a New York City cash buyer based in Ozone Park, a few minutes past the Brooklyn line, buys Coney Island houses as they stand.

Trusted By Coney Island Homeowners In:
the side streets between Mermaid and Neptune Avenues, West 15th and West 16th Streets, the West 30s, the blocks along Neptune Avenue, and the houses inside Sea Gate, plus surrounding Brooklyn neighborhoods including Brighton Beach, Gravesend, Bensonhurst, Bath Beach, Sheepshead Bay, and Manhattan Beach.
7 days
Fastest closing possible
0%
No commissions or closing costs
Local Buyer
Serving Long Island & NYC

Why Coney Island Homeowners Sell To Prime Realty Buyers

On these blocks, most calls trace back to one week in October 2012 or to the family decisions that came after it. Some owners raised their houses, some patched them, and some never moved back in. We buy all three.

Sellers across Coney Island reach out to us when they're dealing with:

Every offer comes in writing with the reasoning attached, so you can weigh it against the cost of one more rebuild.

Why Choose Prime Realty Buyers

Prime Realty Buyers is a New York City cash buyer with an office in Ozone Park, a few minutes past the Brooklyn line, and a person, not a menu, answers when you call about a Coney Island house. The same person climbs the stairs of the raised house or walks the gutted first floor before writing the offer. You see how each number was reached, flood damage included.

You’ll have written proof that the cash is there before you sign anything. Your attorney reads the contract and a title company holds the closing, and you set the date, whether that’s next week or after the last heir signs. If a referee’s sale is already scheduled, tell us on the first call so we can plan around it.

Offer on paper within 24 hours, reasoning included

Funds verified on paper before signing

Your proceeds lose nothing to commission or closing costs

Flood damage and raised houses bought as-is

Your closing date, as soon as 7 days from now

Nearby Brooklyn Areas We Also Buy In

We buy across the Coney Island peninsula and the neighborhoods just past it, including:

Back to Brooklyn: all areas we serve

Real Coney Island Seller Stories

Probate Property

“We still had bare studs on the ground floor from Sandy when Pop died, and his two-family on West 35th Street went into probate. My sister and I couldn’t finish the work and keep up the taxes while Surrogate’s Court took its time. Prime Realty Buyers signed a contract while we waited, included the open walls in the first number, and closed eight days after our Letters arrived.”

Jorge C., Coney Island
Inherited House

“None of us live in New York anymore, so when Grandma left her house on West 16th Street to me and my two brothers, nobody could watch it. I’m in North Carolina, one brother is in Georgia, and the other is stationed overseas. Our attorney arranged the signatures, Prime Realty Buyers bought the house in the flood zone with Grandma’s things still inside, and we closed in six weeks without anyone flying up.”

Darlene U., Coney Island
Flood Zone

“Sandy’s water came at our house on West 36th Street from the creek side, and for years afterward the basement smelled of it no matter what we did. An inspector for one buyer found mold behind the paneling, and that sale ended there. Prime Realty Buyers bought the house with the paneling still up. Chris went over what he’d allowed for the mold and the floors, and we closed in 21 days.”

Maritza Y., Coney Island
Downsizing

“Build It Back raised our two-family near Neptune Avenue after Sandy, and it came back solid. But the new front stairs are long, and after my knee surgery I couldn’t manage them anymore. My wife and I found an apartment with an elevator. Prime Realty Buyers bought the house as it was, Chris came by twice to answer my questions, and we closed on the first of the month like we wanted.”

Nunzio A., Coney Island
Landlord Headache

“I inherited my uncle’s three-family inside Sea Gate and rented it out while working full time in Manhattan. Between storm repairs that never seemed to end, a tenant who stopped paying, and HPD inspections, I was at the gate every weekend. Prime Realty Buyers took the building as it was, tenants, violations, and all, walked me through every number, and closed in 29 days.”

Reggie C., Sea Gate landlord

Sound Like Your Situation?

Raised, patched, or still gutted, we'll put a cash offer in writing.

Our 3-Step Process

1

Contact Us

Call 516-218-0365 or submit your property information. Tell us the Coney Island address, the situation, and your timeline. Five minutes, no obligation.

2

Get A Fair Cash Offer

We do a quick walkthrough, in person or virtual, and present a no-obligation cash offer, usually within 24 hours. We’ll show you exactly how we got to the number.

3

Close On Your Timeline

Need it done in seven days? We can. Need longer to settle an estate, coordinate a move, or wait out a tenant? We can do that too. You sign, we wire, you’re done.

Selling To Prime Realty Buyers Vs Listing In Coney Island

Sell To Prime Realty BuyersTraditional Agent Sale
ConditionSell 100% as-isRepairs often needed
Commissions0% commissionsAgent commission comes out of your proceeds
Closing CostsWe cover closing costsSeller pays a portion
ShowingsNo showings, no open housesWeeks of showings over months
TimelineClose in as little as 7 daysContract, inspection, appraisal, and the lender’s timeline
FinancingNo financing contingencyDeals fall apart at the mortgage commitment
Flooded From Both The Beach And Coney Island CreekBoth kinds of water damage are in our numberBuyers want the damage fixed or credited
Long Stairs Up To A Raised HouseWe buy it raised, stairs and allSome buyers rule out the climb
House Inside Sea Gate’s Private GateOne walkthrough, with gate access arranged by youEvery showing needs gate access arranged
Lease With A Year Left To RunWe buy it with the lease in forceAn owner-occupant buyer has to wait the lease out
Heirs From The Carolinas To Puerto RicoEach heir signs from home; we close by mailA lender’s calendar has to fit every heir’s
Ground Floor Gutted Since 2012We buy it open to the studsBuyers expect finished walls and floors

Frequently Asked Questions, Coney Island

Preguntas Frecuentes

Hablamos español. Llámenos al 516-218-0365.

Done Rebuilding After Every Storm?

Raised or not, repaired or not, the house sells as it stands today.Call 516-218-0365, and we'll walk the house and put a cash number in writing within 24 hours.
No obligation. No pressure. No fees, ever.